Filters Close slideover Filters Collection Other Specialties Toppings Chocolate Thoughts Special Considerations Gluten Friendly Dairy Friendly Vegan Friendly Occasion New Baby Wedding Birthday Thank You Sort By Recommended Most Recent Least Expensive Most Expensive Filter Ice Cream Topping Tote $109.00 Milk & Dark Caramel Pecan Patties - 2 Box Set $48.00 Milk Chocolate Caramel Pecan Patties - Box of 6 $24.00 Dark Chocolate Caramel Pecan Patties - Box of 6 $24.00 Toffee & Almonds $13.75 Peanut Butter Cups $12.75 Caramel Pretzels $12.75 Milk Chocolate Butter Cookies - Bag of 6 $8.75 Indiana Popcorn Tasting Bar $7.50 Mint Cookie Crunch Tasting Bar $7.50 Sea Salt Splash Tasting Bar $7.50 Hazelnut Sea Salt Crisp Tasting Bar $7.50 Tart Red Raspberry Tasting Bar $7.50 Milk Chocolate Tasting Bar $7.50 82% Dark Chocolate Tasting Bar $7.50 72% Dark Chocolate Tasting Bar $7.50 White Chocolate Tasting Bar $7.50 Raspberry Cream - Box of 5 $10.75 Rose Carmella - Box of 5 $10.75 Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels - Box of 5 $10.75 Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels - Box of 5 $10.75 Chocolate Race Car $5.50 Pennies From Heaven $5.50 Caramel Pecan Patty Individual - Milk $4.00 Load More